Saturday, April 6, 2013

The Sun Part 6: Photosphere and Chromosphere

Turbulent and chaotic magnetic activity in the convection zone of the Sun is behind the appearance of sunspots, prominences, solar flares, coronal loops, and coronal mass ejections, all of which are surface and atmospheric features that signal intensifying solar activity as the Sun approaches solar maximum. Other features such as granules and spicules populate the Sun continuously, regardless of its activity. Exactly how all these features form and work remains, in large part, a mystery, one that scientists are actively working on.

Below is a NASA diagram of the Sun's layers.


The photosphere is the Sun's surface. Since a star doesn't have a solid boundary like a planet, moon or meteor does, this boundary is defined a bit differently, as you will see. The chromosphere is a layer of atmosphere just above the surface. It too is unlike any terrestrial atmosphere. It is a turbulent, hot and unpredictable mixture of plasma and atoms. Physicists have an arsenal of imagers and telescopes trained on it in an attempt to pry open some of its fascinating mystery.

In the previous article, we examined why the Sun experiences periods of relative calm followed by periods of intense solar storms. In this article and the next one, we will investigate the visible evidence of solar activity on the surface of the Sun and in its atmosphere.

Sunspots

As the Sun approaches solar maximum, sunspots, intense magnetic knots that spiral outward, tend to show up while the magnetic dipole field as a whole wanes. Magnetic field lines have been wound up and twisted by the Sun's differential rotation, and now the stress has reached its limit. They unfurl upward like uncoiling springs, puncturing the surface of the Sun, called the photosphere. These lines usually come in pairs and when they do, they have opposite polarities like the north and south poles of a magnet. This is why you often, but not always, see identical pairs of sunspots, like the pair shown below. Sunspots appear dark because they are zones where magnetic activity inhibits the motion of convection. Cooler zones that are between 2700°C and 4200°C form in contrast to the average surface temperature of 5500°C around them.

SiriusB;wikipedia
Sunspots look almost black but they are actually very bright, brighter than the moon's surface. The reason why they appear so dark has to do with black body thermodynamics. Very hot objects glow. They give off light, like a hot briquette does. The colour of the light tells you what the temperature of the object is. As the temperature of a hot object falls, its colour changes. This is called black body radiation and you can explore it in my article Atoms and Heat.  If we compare a change in colour (which is photon wavelength) to the change in luminosity or brightness, the luminosity decreases on a scale of about 4 to 1. See how peak visible luminosity (the two black dots) differs between 5400°C and 3000°C in the graph below right. That's approximately the temperature difference between a sunspot and the surrounding surface. The difference in luminosity is quite drastic.

Why Sunspots are "Cool"

Where the magnetic field is extra intense, additional force is exerted on the charged particles in the plasma, disrupting its convective motion. Recent SOHO data reveals powerful downdrafts spiraling downward underneath a sunspot, like a hurricane on Earth.

The process works like an eddy current brake where a magnetic field creates eddy currents in a rotating metal disk. This mechanism makes use of Lenz's law. The eddy currents in the disk set up a magnetic field opposite to one that is already present, and the disk resists rotation. Modern roller coasters use a linear version of these brakes. Inside a sunspot, where magnetic field lines puncture the photosphere, strong eddy currents disrupt the upward motion of convection, so heat from the interior is not transferred upward as efficiently and the sunspot cools.

Below is a close-up SOT telescopic image of two sunspots, roughly 20,000 km across. Notice the fine granular structure of the surrounding surface. These granules (each less than 1000 km across) are the tops of relatively tiny convection cells. Each granule lasts only about 20 minutes which means the surface continually changes over time. Because convection is inhibited in the black-appearing sunspots, they look smooth in comparison. The flow of plasma upward in the granular convection cells is very fast - up to 25,000 km/h. It creates shock waves when it reaches the far less dense photosphere above. The shock of these pressure waves regularly sends waves rippling across the Sun's surface.


In the previous article, we explored the convective layer. This layer of the Sun, underneath the photosphere, is where the granules are created. It is a layer of fluid plasma that literally boils like candy boiling in a pot, except that this fluid has incredibly low density. At the top surface of the layer, the photosphere, the density is only 4 x 10-7 g/cm3 on average. That is thousands of times less dense than air at sea level on Earth, which is 1.5 x 10-3 g/cm3.

Convection is driven by a difference in temperature. The base of the convective layer, where it transitions from the radiative zone, is very hot, about 1,500,000°C. Thermal columns, shown as loops in the image below, carry the hot plasma (shown as red) to the surface of the Sun where it cools off tremendously (blue), to about 5500°C, before it sinks back down and reheats.

modified from Eryian Con-struct;Wikipedia
These thermal columns extend right up to the photosphere lending it the granular appearance you saw in the photograph above. The plasma is full of charged particles in motion, so the turbulence produces magnetic dipoles as well as magnetic fields all over the surface.

The Photosphere

The surface of the Sun marks the layer in which photons of visible light, ultraviolet (UV) light and infrared light escape into space and become visible to imagers, telescopes and the naked eye. As you go downward underneath this layer, photons are increasingly trapped as they are absorbed by electrons and re-emitted. This means that the photosphere is also the boundary underneath which the Sun is completely opaque to electromagnetic radiation (http://solarscience.msfc.nasa.gov/surface.shtml). Even though the plasma is thousands of times less dense than air just beneath the photosphere, light doesn't shine through it as it would through air because free electrons scatter photons, making the plasma opaque at distances over a few hundred kilometres. Opacity means that photons cannot travel through, and it depends on the energy of the photon and the material. Human tissues, except bone, are transparent to X-rays for example. Although we think of Earth's atmosphere as being transparent to light it isn't. As we will see, even visible light is scattered in it to some extent and, luckily for us, Earth's atmosphere is completely opaque to the Sun's extreme UV photons and all of its X-rays.

The photosphere is only about 100 km thick, a very thin boundary compared to the 1.4 million km diameter of the Sun. It is easy to figure out where the surface of a rocky planet like Earth is, but for stars, the boundary is less obvious. The Sun's atmosphere is composed of the layers we can see through with various instruments.

As you move inward through the photosphere and deep into the core of the Sun, you find a trend toward photons becoming more and more trapped and having more and more energy. Average photon energy increases from visible to ultraviolet to X-rays and finally to the extremely energetic gamma rays created in the core's fusion reaction. Photons lose a tiny bit of energy each time they collide with another particle such as an electron in the plasma, so what starts out as gamma rays eventually ends up as much lower energy photons leaving the Sun's surface. The Sun's output is a continuous spectrum that ranges from high frequency X-rays to very low frequency radio waves, but the vast majority of photons range from 100 nm (ultraviolet) to 1 mm (infrared), peaking in radiance at around 580 nm, which is the wavelength of yellow light. The higher energy X-rays I mentioned don't originate from fusion in the core. These energetic photons come from coronal loops, flares and coronal mass ejections, violent structures in the atmosphere that we will explore in the next article.

The Sun is Yellow, No, White!

The Sun's output peaks at yellow visible light. Is that why the Sun appears yellow in the sky? The answer is no, and it is a very good question. The Sun's spectrum is a good approximation of the Sun's surface temperature, about 5500°C, which we explored in The Sun Part 5. Most of the photon emissions from the surface are visible yellow light, but the Sun as a hot body also glows, like a filament in a light bulb. This (black body) glow is called incandescence, and it overlaps and overwhelms its emission spectrum. This may seem confusing because the Sun in the sky looks yellow to us. The Sun's incandescence is the glowing light it gives off because it is very hot, and the Sun is white-hot. This is the Sun's true colour, how it looks from the International Space Station. It looks yellow instead of white in the sky because white sunlight (made up of a balanced spectrum of all visible colours) is scattered a bit more toward the blue end of the spectrum by gas atoms in the atmosphere than red light is. It looks yellow as a result of this light scattering effect, rather than as a result of its peak emission wavelength being yellow light.

Note: The Sun appears yellow in the two sunspot images shown earlier because either attenuation filters are used on solar telescopes, blocking most of the overwhelming brightness and maximizing yellow light (as with the whole Sun image), or the images are taken in black and white and then recolourized (the sunspot close-up). Click here to learn how to view the Sun yourself safely, using either Welder's glass or by using filters with your own telescope.

The Photosphere is Very Weakly Ionized Plasma

The photosphere is white-hot and though it is hot, this temperature is cool enough to allow almost all the hydrogen and all the helium to exist in atomic form as gases. Helium is a very tightly bound atom with the highest ionization energy of all the elements. It will completely ionize (lose both its electrons) only at energies above 5251 kJ/mol. It will partially ionize (lose one electron) at energies above 2372 kJ/mol. The photosphere is not hot enough even to partially ionize helium atoms, but about 3% of hydrogen atoms are ionized. Hydrogen will ionize at much lower energies, above 1312 kJ/mol and it is fully ionized as it only has one electron to lose.

Faculae and Supergranules

When the Sun approaches solar maximum, it actually tends to brighten slightly (about 0.1% overall), despite the increasing appearance of dimmer sunspots. This is because extra bright areas, called faculae, are also showing up across the surface. Like sunspots, these are associated with areas of increased magnetic activity, but the magnetic flux in this case is concentrated into much smaller bundles. They do not interfere with convection the same way that sunspots do. In fact, their mechanism is unrelated to sunspot production. These bright spots are regions where the magnetic field is extra intense and this force reduces the density of the photosphere gas so much that it makes it transparent. You can see right through into deeper layers of the granules where the plasma is hotter and brighter.

Supergranules are much larger than granules, about 35,000 km across. These structures last about a day, much longer than the smaller granules do. The origin of supergranules is not known but some researchers believe they are a higher-order pattern of granulation, part of a convection hierarchic structure, in other words. They are the focus of current research. The SOHO image of the Sun below reveals a web-like pattern or network across the Sun's surface that outlines supergranule cells.


This red, white and blue image is a Doppler-shift SOHO image. Red supergranules are moving into the Sun while blue supergranules are moving outward toward the surface. It highlights where bundles of magnetic field lines in the chromosphere are concentrated by the motions of supergranules in the photosphere underneath.

The chromosphere is the innermost part of the Sun's atmosphere. Here, additional solar features, such as filaments, spicules and prominences can be observed.

The chromosphere gets its "chromo" or colour name from hydrogen. The temperature rises in this irregular layer from about 5500°C to about 20,000°C. At these temperatures most hydrogen atoms are in an excited state and they emit (mostly) red light. If you look at the Sun through an H-alpha (660 nm) filter on a telescope, which isolates this colour, you can see all the features of this layer, as in the NASA photo below.


Although this light is in the visible range, you can't see it without an H-alpha filter. It is overwhelmed by the much brighter photosphere beneath it. If you want to see the photosphere features mentioned earlier, such as sunspots, you just need a good telescope that filters out some of the Sun's brightness, because most of this light, too, is in the visible range.

The chromosphere is much more enigmatic than researchers thought a few decades ago. Now, they don't restrict their observations of the Sun's chromospheric features to an H-alpha filter. As we will see, some structures in this layer exhibit a far more complex and puzzling temperature range, which extends far beyond 20,000°C.  At these higher more energetic temperatures, ultraviolet and X-ray imaging are used instead, because these structures are invisible to the naked eye.

Prominences

If you look closely at the red Sun image above, you will see dark thread-like filaments. These are slightly cooler clouds of gas suspended by magnetic field loops. Denser larger filaments of material projecting well above the surface of the Sun are called prominences. An example is shown in the orange/red image below. Prominences, which can be as huge as 800,000 km across, are often shaped like loops anchored in the photosphere. They tend to form over a day and then last for several months. Scientists are not sure why and how they form. When the Sun is quiescent, prominences tend to be relatively cool. These ones are virtually indistinguishable from dark filaments, when viewed directly top-down. They do not move or change much for days or weeks on end before dissolving unceremoniously. Others seem much more unstable. These ones tend to form during periods of higher activity, lasting only hours or minutes before erupting without warning into solar flares or coronal mass ejections, CME's.

The plasma in the prominence flows along magnetic flux lines. As these magnetic flux lines become increasingly twisted and disorganized (usually by the action of the solar dynamo), the prominence will grow increasingly unstable. It may eventually erupt, ejecting a significant amount of plasma from the Sun. The shockwave of this fast-traveling mass of plasma and radiation may cause a geomagnetic storm  if it shoots off in Earth's direction.

Prominences are a bit of a mystery because, while most observations place them at around 6000°C to 10,000°C, well within the temperature range of the chromosphere, these structures can be gigantic, extending well into the outer coronal layer, where temperatures spike to 1,000,000°C. New research suggests that prominences might be inner structures inside larger formations, like a filament inside a light bulb, except in this case, the "filament" plasma is much cooler than the hollow croissant-shaped "light bulb" or cavity of plasma that surrounds it. Scientists are curious about the vast range in temperature and about how some prominences seem to exist for weeks, appearing quite stable, before they suddenly erupt into massive CME's. Understanding how prominences work and how instability develops in them could help researchers predict potentially catastrophic CME's before they are observed on their way to Earth.

The image of a prominence below was taken by NASA's SDO observatory. Jupiter and Earth are juxtaposed on the image to show just how large one of these can be.

This image was taken in the extreme ultraviolet range, about 30.4 nm. The ultraviolet emissions are from highly ionized iron and from singly ionized helium and it corresponds to a temperature of about 50,000°C. There is a tiny amount of iron and other heavy elements in the corona and in the Sun in general. They came in the gas/dust cloud from which the Sun formed. In this image you are seeing the structure of the corona. Normally we can't see the corona because its black body radiation peaks in the invisible extreme UV range and because the Sun's visible output (from the photosphere) is a billion times brighter than the extreme UV output from the corona. A special filter is required to block it from the imager.

Prominences can also be easily observed in visible light using an H-alpha filter (660 nm). Below is a time-lapse movie of an H-alpha prominence shot in 2010:



Prominences look a bit like coronal loops (one is shown below for comparison which we will explore in detail in the next article), but there are key differences between them. Prominences tend to be much cooler than coronal loops. The plasma in a prominence (and at least the inner "filament" within a large unstable prominence) is about the same temperature as the rest of the chromosphere, so they are visible using a hydrogen alpha filter. Coronal loops, on the other hand are not visible in the visible spectrum at all, while even the hottest prominences have a visible component. NASA's TRACE images coronal loops filled with intensely hot (1,000,000°C) completely ionized plasma using a 17 nm (X-ray) filter. An example is shown below.



Perhaps even more mysterious than prominences, coronal loops are filled with mystery all their own, which we will dive into in the next article.

Spicules

Finally, spicules, or solar flux tubes as they are sometimes called, are tiny jets of material that erupt all over the Sun's surface and up through the chromosphere all the time, ejecting material outward into the upper atmosphere at speeds of around 90,000 km/h. They look like orange fur (along with a prominence to the left) in the NASA image below.


Like many solar surface features, spicules are under intense investigation right now. Careful observations using SOHO, TRACE and Sweden's SST telescope, along with computer modelling revealed in 2004 that spicules are probably formed by plasma energy waves that leak into the low atmosphere where they turn into shock waves. Spicules have an interesting regular periodicity. A new one appears in the same spot every 5 minutes. The waves that cause them have the same 5-minute periodicity. These waves, created by interacting electric and magnetic fields in moving plasma, resonate inside the Sun. Most of the waves are damped down by inner plasma flows where they are trapped and echo back and forth, but some of them escape, creating shock waves in the process, and these shock waves hurl jets of plasma out with them, creating spicules. The shock waves propel hundreds of thousands of spicules across the Sun's surface at any given time.

Though individual spicules are small, they add up, carrying hundreds of times more mass into the atmosphere than what would be needed to explain solar wind using ballistics mechanics. More recent (2011) evidence suggests that spicules could be related to prominences.  Plasma shot upward by spicules may rain back down when it cools in the upper solar atmosphere, and as it does, it might be captured in the tangled trap of a prominence's magnetic flux lines. In the 1980's, researchers, observing that spicule plasma appeared to be as cool as the rest of the chromospheric plasma, discarded spicules as a possible cause of mysterious coronal heating, something we will investigate in the next article. However, in 2011, NASA's SDO measured some spicule plasma temperatures at over 1 million degrees Celsius, bringing spicules back into the spotlight as serious coronal heating contenders. Other research from 2011 suggests that spicules in the chromosphere and granules in the photosphere beneath them might be related to each other somehow and that the spicules might be generating a continuous supply of waves called Alfvén waves. These waves have been modeled to have enough energy to heat the corona and power solar wind as well.

We will revisit these special Alfvén waves in the next article when we explore the outer layers of the Sun's atmosphere and one of the Sun's most intriguing puzzles - the coronal heating mystery, next.

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

The Sun Part 7: The Corona

The Sun's corona is the outermost layer of the Sun's atmosphere and it is enormous, extending from the chromosphere beneath it to more than a million kilometres into space. This layer, composed mostly of ionized hydrogen atoms, has an average density far less than even that of the chromosphere, and its outermost edge vanishes into the near-vacuum density of interplanetary space. This layer is about a million times less bright than the overwhelming radiance of the Sun's surface. Despite the relative coolness of the chromosphere below (it generally reaches a maximum of about 20,000°C), this layer mysteriously approaches temperatures well over 1,000,000°C. Why it is so hot is a question physicists are busy trying to answer.

Viewing the Corona

Amateur astronomers like us can only see the Sun's corona during a solar eclipse, when the far brighter solar surface is blocked behind the moon, as shown below.

Luc Viatour;Wikipedia


It might be tempting to peer at the Sun during an eclipse, thinking that it should be safe to do so, but it isn't. Even a tiny sliver of exposed photosphere emits enough UV radiation to permanently damage the eye's retina, and there are no pain receptors there so you won't be aware of it. Sunglasses (even UV ones), smoked glass, CD's or black camera film don't work. Astronomy sites recommend that we use only a proper solar filter or Shade #14 Welder's glasses. The next total eclipse depends on where you are on Earth. NASA provides an eclipse website that predicts the next partial and total eclipses around the world.



The Corona is Like a Very Hot, Very Light Gas

Plasma acts like a highly compressed liquid where convection takes place inside the Sun, but in the corona, hydrogen is completely ionized and helium is partly or completely ionized and they act more like very hot very light gases, with important differences. The density here is about a million times less than Earth's atmosphere.

The coolest layer of the Sun, around 3800°C, is found about 500 km above the Sun's surface. This is part of the chromosphere, the lowest layer of the atmosphere. If we go from 500 km outwards to about 2000 km altitude, the temperature rises very sharply, from 3800°C to over 1,000,000°C. This zone is called the transition region. Its actual thickness and altitude are variable and not well defined. This region is hot enough to completely ionize helium atoms and partly ionize various heavier trace elements present as well, such as iron. This zone is filled with extremely low-density, extremely energetic, plasma that ranges from 1.0 x 10-14 g/cm3 at the bottom of the zone to about 1.0 x 10-16 g/cm3 at the top. Compare this to the density of the chromosphere, about 2 x 10-7 g/cm3.

The Corona Transitions Into Solar Wind

At the top of the corona, electrons, protons and a few other particles escape the Sun into surrounding space. These fast moving particles, combined with radiation emitted from the Sun, make up solar wind. Old models relied on thermal energy to accelerate the particles enough to overcome the Sun's intense gravity. At a million degrees Celsius, these particles, although very far apart, collide with tremendous energy, and this force accelerates them on average to about 145 km/s. This represents their average thermal energy. However, that is well below the velocity they would need to escape the Sun's gravity, about 618 km/s. New models take magnetic and electric interactions into account as well as thermal energy. For example, many electrons in the plasma, being relatively light, in fact do reach escape velocity because this plasma is too diffuse to act like thermal plasma (thermal plasmas are explored in The Sun Part 3). As electrons escape, they build up an electric field that further accelerates other ions away from the Sun, allowing them to escape as well. Magnetism also plays a significant role, especially around solar maximum. Open magnetic field lines make solar wind gusty. These open lines are called coronal holes, and they are usually located at the Sun's magnetic poles during quiescence. They appear as dark spots in UV images of the Sun. A large one is easily visible on the lower right part of the NASA STEREO colourized image taken with an extreme UV 19.5 nm imager, below right.





Remember how magnetic field lines loop around a bar magnet but at the ends, a few lines point straight out or in rather than form a loop? See the magnetic field lines around a bar magnet, below left. The Sun's magnetic field is much the same when it is very quiet. Coronal holes form over the North and South poles.

Coronal holes become very mobile, multiple, and unpredictable during high activity, when the Sun's magnetic field lines become disorganized, twisted and tortured. These holes are like open channels through which ions accelerate up to 800 km/s, well above average escape velocity. Although they operate in both directions - into and away from the Sun - the holes contribute significantly to solar particle loss. When Earth is in line with a coronal hole, increased geomagnetic activity, such as more and brighter aurorae, is expected.

The high thermal energy of solar plasma, augmented by the effects of magnetism and electricity, means that the Sun loses, on average, between 4 and 6 billion metric tonnes of matter every hour.

Coronal Loops

Powerful magnetic fields in the corona have a powerful impact on plasma movement. Plasma tends to "stick" to magnetic field lines. An electron, being a charged particle, will experience a force that is perpendicular to both its direction of motion and the magnetic field, called the Lorentz force. Around a strong magnetic field line, the force is enough to deflect the electron into a circular motion. It becomes trapped into rotating around it. Electrons in the solar plasma (and positive ions going the opposite direction) follow helical paths as they travel along the length of a magnetic field line, as shown below right.



This trapping effect leads to magnificent structures called coronal loops, observed by NASA's TRACE satellite, shown below, which decorate the corona, particularly during solar maximum. The glow is from hot and excited ions trapped along magnetic field lines, illuminating them.


We took a sneak preview of coronal loops in the previous article when we compared them to prominences. This is a colourized 17 nm X-ray image - the ions trapped along the magnetic field lines are extremely energetic. They are emitting a lot of X-ray photons, representing a great deal of radiant energy.

These loops are closed magnetic field lines and they are thought to be harbingers of solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CME's), even though research suggests that CME's are the direct result of prominence eruptions rather than coronal loops. Sunspots are often found at the point where coronal loops originate, called footprints. A pair of footprints anchors each magnetic field loop to the photosphere, each footprint being of opposite polarity. Bright coronal loops, often many thousands of kilometers high, populate the corona at solar maximum, each one lasting hours or days. However, even larger but fainter loops may appear when solar activity is low, and these last longer, up to weeks, a pattern reminiscent of prominences.

The corona is full of open and closed magnetic field lines. A magnetic field line represents a one-way flow of magnetic force. Physicists measure this flow more accurately as magnetic flux but as visualization aids, field lines work fine. The closer the lines are drawn, the greater the flux. Most magnetic field lines around the Sun are "empty" of plasma, but coronal loops are loaded with it. The plasma within them is denser than the surrounding corona, and it glows, indicating where the flux lines are.

Imaging the Corona Using Trace Atoms

The plasma glows around the X-ray range of the EM spectrum because of its incredible heat. It is not accurate to call this output its black body spectrum, however, because the corona is not optically thick enough to act like a black body (the photosphere, on the other hand, is). Along with the heat glow, excited electrons in ions glow as well, adding to the total emission. SOHO, for example, has several solar imagers, each tuned to a specific electromagnetic (EM) wavelength. When the Sun is imaged, the light captured can be attributed to a specific excited ion and a corresponding temperature. For example, the 17 nm X-ray image above indicates the presence of excited partly ionized iron atoms that have lost 8 electrons, Fe IX (a neutral iron atom is called Fe I). These occur at temperatures around 60,000°C (corresponding to an energy of around 15,000 kJ/mol. Carbon, helium and especially iron, present in small to trace amounts in the corona, are very useful because they have a variety of possible excited ion emission wavelengths that allow them to "light up" specific regions and structures, when they are imaged at that wavelength. Flares may be extremely hot, approaching 10,000,000°C. Fe XVIII, excited iron ions with 17 missing electrons, exist at this temperature, emitting photons at 9.4 nm. A 9.4 nm imager will illuminate such a flare in great detail.

Coronal Loop Characteristics

Much about coronal loops remains a mystery, but SOHO observations suggest that plasma flows in one direction through a coronal loop. As it follows the loop into the top of the transition region it is intensely heated before it cools once again on the way back down. The size and height of coronal loops vary widely, as shown below. Smaller loops may not reach the bottom of the transition region where temperatures begin to rise. In the largest loops, however, the plasma undergoes a kind of evaporation (into fully ionized) in the upper part of the loop followed by condensation (to partially ionized and neutral) at the footprint. (The top of the transition region is not shown in the diagram; the dotted line shows where it starts.)


Coronal loops (and especially solar flares) tend to occur around the same time and place as CME's do. It's easy to imagine a loop twisting and a CME being pinched off and hurled into space, but there is no evidence that CME's form this way. Most ejections do, however, come from regions where sunspots are grouped together, indicating intense magnetic activity. And, as mentioned in the previous article evidence suggests that most ejections come from hot destabilized prominences. We will explore CME's in more detail later on in this article.

In the hottest zone of a coronal loop, electrons have enough energy to emit X-rays when they collide with other particles. These are the most energetic photons emitted from the Sun into space. The gamma photon emissions that originate from fusion in the core are not nearly as energetic by the time they leave the Sun. Their upper limit is ultraviolet. Loop X-ray emission carries away a tremendous amount of energy, so why is this layer of the corona so incredibly hot, when it seems to have a powerful built-in cooling mechanism?

Coronal Heating Problem: Two Theories

Over a thin layer of the Sun's atmosphere, temperatures skyrocket up to 1,000,000°C, when it seems the temperature should gradually decrease with altitude. This is observation really puzzles researchers. Coronal loops might be involved in coronal heating somehow. Researchers know the plasma within them is heated by coronal heating, but it's possible they play an active role in the heating process themselves. Recent TRACE images show that significant heating occurs near the footprints of coronal loops where they emerge and where they connect back to the photosphere. You can see evidence of this heating in the image of the loops above, taken in the extreme ultraviolet range, as extra brightness near their bases.

To make the coronal loop mystery even more complex, there seems to be no single-fit temperature profile for coronal loops. Temperatures vary wildly along the length of loops and the loops themselves exhibit a wide variety of overall temperatures. There are cool loops (below 1 million °C), warm loops (around 1 million °C and hot loops (above 1 million °C). If you look at a photo gallery of coronal loops (just search "coronal loops" in Google's image search engine), you will notice a wide range in brightness (depending on the wavelength chosen) as well as overall size. They are, not surprisingly, under intense investigation by researchers.

Two theories for coronal heating stand out. One theory, which has not been directly verified, has to do with the Sun's magnetism. As mentioned in the previous article, the Sun's surface (its photosphere) is granular in appearance because it is covered with many tiny magnetic dipoles. These dipoles are much smaller (50 to 1000 km across) than magnetic field loops, but they may be the force behind coronal heating.

Coronal loops are generally linked to increased solar activity during solar maximum in the 11-year solar cycle. The tiny magnetic dipoles associated with granules, on the other hand, are always present, creating a magnetic carpet that covers the star all the time, even during solar minimum, when the surface is fairly quiet. This is important because the corona always stays hot. Its temperature doesn't go up and down with the solar cycle, so the heating mechanism must be a continuous one.

The mechanism proposed for this theory is the same as it is for CME's - magnetic reconnection. The laws of electromagnetism tell us that magnetic field lines cannot cross one another. When two lines come close to each other they are rearranged on the Sun's surface. This process should release energy when electrical currents along these lines suddenly collapse, and this could heat the corona. In this case, magnetic reconnection occurs on a far smaller and more constant scale than it does for large solar flares and CME's.

In order for the theory to work, there must be a great deal of continuous reconnection going on all over the Sun's surface in order to heat the corona so intensely. Theoretical tiny flares associated with the reconnections, called nanoflares, would be far too small to be observed directly and there is a question of whether they would be widespread enough to account for all the heating. The main problem with this theory is that you have to show how cyclic and extremely energetic large-scale phenomena, like coronal flares and mass ejections, can originate from the same mechanism as continuous, lower energy and tiny granule-associated nanoflares do. No one has been able to do that yet.

A second theory is called the wave heating theory. Two kinds of wave occur specifically in plasma: magneto-acoustic waves and Alfvén waves. These waves may carry energy from the Sun's interior outward and into the corona. Magneto-acoustic waves are longitudinal waves, like sound waves and pressure waves, shown below left. Alfvén waves, on the other hand, travel as transverse waves that are a bit like low frequency radio waves, below right.
Longitudinal Wave
GFDL;wikipedia
Transverse Wave
GFDL;wikipedia
Alfvén waves are an interesting combination of an electromagnetic wave (photons) and a hydrodynamic wave. This is how they are set up: In an electrically conductive fluid, like plasma, any movement of the fluid produces an electric field and a magnetic field. The electrical current, in turn applies mechanical force to the liquid itself, altering its motion and the magnetic field. If you think of a magnetic field line as a string with tension in it, an Alfvén wave is a disturbance traveling along the string once it is plucked by the perturbation in the magnetic field. Plasma tends to move in the same direction as magnetic field lines move. This is why coronal loops contain plasma, as if magnetic field lines are "sticky" to it.  Many field lines are directed outward, piercing the photosphere. An Alfvén wave, therefore, could reverberate plasma along its length and propagate a great deal of energy outward into the corona. Alfvén waves travel much faster in very strong magnetic fields and in areas of very low density, so it could mean that there is increased energy available to heat the very low-density transition region.

Problems With Waves and Nanoflares

Both Alfvén waves and magneto-acoustic waves have been observed on the Sun. The turbulence in the Sun launches both types of wave. These waves may carry energy some distance up through the solar atmosphere.

Magneto-acoustic waves do not offer as much promise as Alfvén waves in explaining coronal heating because of the problems mentioned earlier as well as the fact that the density of the gas in the corona drops so dramatically. These waves, which are pressure waves, shouldn't be able to carry enough energy to the corona fast enough to heat the gases. Many of these waves would also be reflected back onto the photosphere. In 1997, SOHO observations suggest that they account for no more than 10% of coronal heating.

Alfvén waves detected in 2007 were clocked travelling as fast as 2500 km/s (9 million km/h). It's possible that such waves, hitting the transition region, could be transformed into shock waves that quite suddenly dissipate their energy as heat. This theory might explain why the temperature increases so rapidly across a fairly specific layer in the corona (the transition region), but no precise mechanism has been worked out.

It's even more difficult to explain how the granule/nanoflare magnetic reconnection theory accounts for the steep temperature increase well above the photosphere.

Many physicists believe it's possible that no single mechanism heats the corona. Magnetic reconnection, Alfvén waves and magneto-acoustic waves may all contribute to coronal heating.

Keeping the Heat In: Two Mechanisms

Once heat is supplied to the transition region, additional mechanisms appear to be at work keeping heat in this layer.

First, electrons are ultimately responsible for outward directed thermal conduction in the core. They carry kinetic energy that is transferred from collision to collision between photons, protons and nuclei, re-emitting new photons that carry energy slowly outward. This works because the core is so dense and particles are very close together so they can interact a great deal with each other. The transition region of the corona, though almost as hot as plasma is near the base of the convective zone (http://solarscience.msfc.nasa.gov/interior.shtml), is far, far less dense. There are great distances between particles. Here, thermal conduction isn't outward so much as it is parallel to magnetic field lines. The Lorentz force bends the path of plasma along these lines, which tend to run parallel to and across the Sun's surface. Electrons tend to stay in these lines because there are very few collisions to scatter them. This prevents them from the upward perpendicular movement that would allow heat to dissipate upward and outward through the corona.

Second, helium atoms, which account for somewhere between 5% and 15% of the corona by number, are only partially ionized below the transition region but within it, they are energetic (hot) enough to completely ionize. Partially ionized helium radiates energy away very well. This atom still has one of its two electrons, so it can radiate energy away as black body radiation and it can also emit photons as the electron moves from one energy level down to another one. This emission process has the same dynamics as the ultraviolet Lyman series of emission lines observed for hydrogen (see Atoms Part 2: Atoms and Light). The strongest emission is 30.4 nm. The emitted photon carries energy away with it. When a helium atom is fully ionized, however, it has no electrons left at all. Instead it is an alpha particle, a nucleus consisting of two protons and two neutrons. The atom now has no way to effectively lose energy, except through occasional collisions in the very thin coronal atmosphere. Physicists consider this electron-less state to be a kind of phase transition. It goes a long way in explaining how such a steep temperature gradient can exist in the corona. It doesn't take a very large increase in heat to fully ionize helium once it is partially ionized. Once this happens, heat has almost no way to dissipate from the region (an exception is energy dissipation through X-ray iron emission but iron is present in only trace amounts). Likewise, if the temperature decreases just slightly, helium returns to a partially ionized state where heat can rapidly be further dissipated.

Coronal Mass Ejection

The corona is very hot and, especially near solar maximum, very chaotic. Although ions are few and far between, the corona is nonetheless a gigantic reservoir of material. Billions of tonnes of coronal matter can be hurled from the Sun in just one coronal mass ejection, or CME. CME's remain very mysterious to scientists. Massive loops of coronal material are hurled away from the Sun at speeds of over 1,000,000 km/h. Furthermore, CME's have roughly ten times the energy of the prominences that produced them. Although the mechanism is not well understood, most physicists believe that CME's are caused by magnetic reconnection. This process happens anywhere magnetic fields exist in space. It is very common in the Earths' magnetosphere as well as on the Sun. But, maybe surprisingly, magnetic reconnection on the Sun is not yet understood. Scientists do have a basic idea of what happens - in order to build a CME, two bundles of oppositely directed magnetic flux must come very close together. This isn't hard to fathom because oppositely directed magnetic fields attract each other - that's how magnets work. On the Sun, these magnetic field lines are strongly stretched out by plasma pressure, which means they have a lot of potential energy, like stretched out rubber bands. The lines come close, almost cross, and then cancel and reconnect as new, now relaxed, parallel lines, and they release a tremendous amount of magnetic potential energy doing it, often equivalent to millions of hydrogen bombs. The problem with modeling (and understanding) CME's is that the classical theory used to model how electrically conductive plasma behaves, called magnetohydrodynamics, does not accurately predict how powerful and how fast magnetic reconnection occurs in CME's. It is also difficult to model these complex processes in three dimensions, even with the latest software.

The Halloween 2003 Solar Storm Captured by SOHO

To highlight just how challenging it is to predict and understand solar activity, the Halloween 2003 solar storm, one of the most powerful solar storms ever recorded by modern imagers, occurred two to three years after solar maximum, at a time when the Sun's magnetic activity should have been waning. Between October 19th and November 7th, a total of 17 solar flares erupted. For unknown reasons, the Sun's magnetic field stretched and snapped like a rubber band, triggering a series of CME's that hurled billions of tonnes of material in all directions at speeds up to 8 million km/h. A solar storm becomes a geomagnetic storm when clouds of charged particles from CME's, as well as extra intense solar wind, crash into Earth's magnetic field, disrupting it and causing it to reverberate like a trampoline. Vibrant auroras associated with the 2003 storm were seen as far south as Florida as flights, satellites and telecommunications were disrupted and parts of Sweden lost power. SOHO failed temporarily and NASA's ACE satellite (designed to study the composition of solar wind) was damaged.

A particular solar flare and accompanying CME on October 28, 2003, was the most powerful flare scientifically recorded. It produced an X-ray flux of X45, which saturated X-ray imaging instruments for 11 minutes. Solar flares vary widely in strength. Some are barely detectible while others send powerful radiation all the way to Earth, so scientists rate their strength on a power-ten system like earthquakes. Flares are ranked class A, B, C, M and X with each letter representing a 10-fold increase in strength. Within each letter, there is a finer scale from 1 to 9. X-class flares can go even higher than 9, so an X45 flare, the most powerful ever recorded (and adjusted upward from an original measurement of X28), is 45 times more powerful than an X1 flare, which is 10,000 times more powerful than an A class flare.

Luckily, the bulk of it just missed Earth.

Even so, SOHO managed to get some fascinating footage of the storming Sun, in a variety of wavelengths, highlighting what was happening in various layers of the solar atmosphere. Each movie is 30 seconds long and is compiled from the same two weeks of data.

In the first movie, SOHO's MDI (Michelson Doppler Imager) approximated a full-spectrum visible light image of the Sun from several narrow bandwidths of visible light. You can see several sunspot-dense regions in the photosphere:



At the same time, SOHO's extreme ultraviolet imaging telescope (EIT), set at 30.4 nm, captured this series of images in extreme ultraviolet:



30.4 nm is the emission line of singly ionized helium, mostly present at temperatures between 60,000°C and 80,000°C. This temperature range corresponds to an atmospheric layer of keen interest to scientists - the transition region between the chromosphere and the corona above it. This is the region you are seeing in the movie above.

The EIT also captured images set at 19.5 nm, capturing even more energetic UV radiation:



19.5 nm is the emission line of Fe XII, present at temperatures of over 1.5 million °C. Fe XII is a partly ionized iron ion with 11 of its electrons removed (Fe I is a neutral iron atom). There are relatively few iron ions present in the corona but they can be selectively viewed when their specific emission wavelength of 19.5 nm is picked out of the total emission spectrum. These images highlight activity in the hottest region of the corona, just above the transition region.

The same imager also captured a much larger field of 19.5 nm coronal radiation extending from the solar disk. The Sun's photosphere was blocked out entirely in order to capture this far dimmer radiation, and the Sun's 19.5 nm image is placed overtop to give viewers an idea of how much larger this field of view is:



The movie above shows how incredibly hot and energetic the plasma in solar flares can be.

CME's, flares and solar wind have a far-reaching impact on the planets and moons that orbit the Sun. In fact, the Sun impacts a region as large as 100 astronomical units (AU), or 15 billion km on average. We'll explore the Sun's region of influence, called the heliosphere, next.

Monday, April 1, 2013

The Sun Part 8: The Sun's Heliosphere

The idea that the Sun has a heliosphere came together in the late 1950's with the work of several researchers studying cosmic rays. They knew that solar wind somehow blocked interstellar cosmic rays (discovered a few decades earlier) from bombarding Earth and other planets. The heliosphere concept was quickly fleshed out into the idea that the matter, photons and magnetic flux of solar wind push the interstellar medium outward, blocking out most interstellar radiation and matter from interplanetary space. The heliosphere model didn't change much since its inception, until 2012. New research is now forcing researchers to readjust everything they know about what the heliosphere looks like and how it works.

Creating a Heliosphere

Plasma movement inside the Sun means there are great flows of moving charge. These moving charges generate intense and mobile magnetic fields that surround the Sun. The magnetic fields not only supply forces that push on and accelerate charged particles in the plasma but they also extend outward into space, having an impact. The Sun also contains an inner magnetic dynamo that greatly intensifies its magnetic field. We explored how the Sun's dynamo works in the second part of The Sun Part 5. Basically, plasma experiences mechanical shear in the region between the calm inner radiation zone and the outer turbulent convection zone. This shear force drags and distorts magnetic field lines, bringing them together and greatly amplifying the existing magnetic field. The Sun's magnetic field is so powerful that its influence extends well past Pluto, although its exact range is unknown. It creates a bubble of influence called the heliosphere. The heliosphere ends at an outer boundary called the heliopause, shown in the NASA artist's rendition below.


This bubble of influence is filled with solar wind, the charged particles and radiation that stream in all directions at an average velocity of around 400 m/s from the Sun's surface and corona. It might look like the space between objects in our solar system is just an empty vacuum but it isn't. It contains particles and it exerts pressure. The flow of particles from the Sun eventually meets up with interstellar space. Interstellar space too, is not a vacuum. It contains ions, gas atoms and dust (small molecules), as well as radiation from distant stars, all of which exert pressure against the heliosphere bubble, especially along its leading edge. Interstellar space bumps up against the outer edge of the heliosphere, slowing solar wind down and eventually overcoming it altogether.

The actual shape of the heliosphere (everything inside the heliopause labeled in the diagram above) appears to be more complex than the above image lets on. Because the Sun rotates (once very 27 days), its magnetic field corkscrews outward. If you could see the magnetic field lines above the poles, they would spiral upward like a slinky. The NOAA site models the real-time density and speed of plasma as if you are looking down at the North Pole of the Sun from a great distance. This information comes from the two stereo satellites of the NASA STEREO mission.

Copyright:NASA
The solar plasma stream therefore has a distinctive spiral swirl shape (shown in two circular plots to the left on the NOAA webpage). This gives you a good idea of where the magnetic field lines are, because the streaming plasma (solar wind) tends to follow these lines.

Below is a computer model image of the heliospheric current sheet. The Sun is shown in the middle. Earth is the tiny third planet out.


This image models the equatorial plane of the Sun's magnetic field. Rather than a smooth plane, it is ruffled like a ballerina's skirt because of the effect of the Sun's rotation on the plasma streaming from it.

The Sun Experiences Two Kinds Of Movement Through Interstellar Space

If you look again at the first heliosphere (blue/black) image, you can see red arrows coming in from the left. That is interstellar space bumping up against the heliosphere. This happens because the Sun isn't stationary. The Sun experiences two kinds of movement. It moves through space, following a kind of wavy orbit around the gravitational center of the Milky Way, shown below as a NASA artist's rendition.


The Sun is about 26,000 light years from the center of the Milky Way, and this means its orbital speed is very high, about 782,000 km/h. Even at this rate, it takes the Sun 226 million years to complete a single orbit. As the Sun orbits it moves up and down through the galactic plane. One complete up-down cycle takes 64 million years. Like the bow shock which is thought, until recently, to be part of the heliosheath (you can see it labeled in the blue/black heliosphere image far above), the galaxy itself has a bow shock. There is new evidence that the galaxy, in fact, has a powerful magnetosphere of its own. Scientists recently identified giant geysers of magnetized gamma-ray-emitting gas spewing from the galactic center, representing a tremendous amount of magnetic energy. There is an artist's image of these gamma ray geysers, or bubbles, later in this article.

The Milky Way galactic bow shock faces the Virgo Cluster as our galaxy moves toward it, and it should cause superheated gas and cosmic rays to stream behind. Cosmic rays are high-energy particles, mostly free protons, which usually come from supernovae but may also come from galactic bow shock. Cosmic ray energy varies widely from 109 eV to 1021 eV. A (subatomic) proton with 1021 eV of energy has as much kinetic energy as a 90-km/h baseball. We will explore cosmic rays in more detail later on in this article. It's not known how energetic galactic bow shock cosmic rays are, if they exist.

Life on Earth is generally not impacted by cosmic rays. Almost all but the most energetic cosmic rays are blocked out by the heliosphere and Earth's atmosphere, but cosmic radiation does become more significant with altitude and it splits ozone in the ozone layer, which protects life from damaging ultraviolet radiation. DNA is particularly vulnerable to high-energy radiation so even small increase of cosmic rays striking the surface could have disastrous effects on life.

Scientists speculate that once every 64 million years, when the solar system emerges from the denser galactic disk, the solar system may be more exposed to these cosmic rays, leading to more penetrating the Sun's and Earth's protective magnetospheres. Marine fossil records offer some support. They show that biodiversity increases and decreases on a roughly similar 62 million-year cycle. Scientists are continuing to look for links between the Sun's galactic environment and past extinction events. This line of research though relatively new, highlights how important the heliosphere is in protecting life on Earth from cosmic radiation. We will revisit this idea too, later on in this article.

The Sun's orbiting motion would not be the cause of heliospheric bow shock. This is because all the other stars and gas (at this radius) are generally moving at the same rate. They all move together in the same giant swirl, so the Sun is not invading "new" interstellar space. If it were, there would indeed be bow shock. At 782,000 km/h, the forces would be disastrous. The Sun also experiences movement relative to its neighbours and the neighbouring interstellar medium, and here, the Sun is invading "new" interstellar space. For decades, researchers believed this movement created bow shock at the leading edge of the heliosphere. Let's first examine what bow shock is.

The Edge of the Helioshpere: Bow Shock?

Solar wind and interstellar space can both be technically called cold plasmas, thanks to their significant but highly diffuse ionized content. Like other fluids, air and water for example, the Sun's heliosphere, until recently, was expected to experience bow shock along its leading edge as the Sun moves through interstellar space, in the same way that a high speed jet creates a sonic boom in the air when it accelerates past the speed of sound, past Mach 1.

Pressure waves get compressed ahead of the jet (and the Sun). In a sonic boom, they are forced to merge into one giant shock wave that travels at the speed of sound. When a jet flies faster than Mach 1, the pressure wave can't keep up. It creates a boom carpet on the ground that trails the jet (with a width that depends on the jet's altitude). Along this carpet, windows rattle and people hear a cracking boom that lasts about a tenth of a second, much louder than the crack of a bullwhip or fireworks, which are also (smaller) sonic booms.
Sound is a mechanical disturbance traveling through a medium, which can be gas, liquid or solid. Space acts like an extremely diffuse gas. There may be enough particles to technically carry a disturbance but a listening instrument would have to be extremely sensitive to pick such "space sounds" up. Instead, scientific instruments in space "listen" to electromagnetic waves - which don't require a medium to travel through - such as radio waves, microwaves and light, for example The bow shock of the heliosphere would work a bit differently than a sonic boom but it follows the same basic idea. The heliospheric shock wave should trail the Sun the same way as sonic boom does, but from here the mechanism differs. The disturbance of a sound wave in air moves through relatively stationary gas molecules. In solar wind, the particles themselves are moving, and their movement is influenced by the magnetic field they are embedded in.

The charged particles in the solar wind follow helical paths around magnetic field lines that extend from the Sun through interplanetary space. The velocity of these gyrating or corkscrewing particles can be treated the same as thermal velocity in a gas. In an ideal gas, the average thermal velocity is close to the speed of sound through that gas. At bow shock, particles in the supersonic interstellar wind bunch up at the front of the shock, as heliospheric pressure waves bunch up against each other. The velocity of the solar wind (the vector component of the particle velocity that is forward-directed) is forced below the speed at which the particles are gyrating. In this way, it quickly goes from supersonic to subsonic, and it is the quick change in density that is the bow shock itself, just like the air/jet example. Many examples of visible bow shock have been observed throughout the galaxy, leading researchers to believe the Sun should be no exception. This Hubble image of a star in the Orion Nebula below is a great example of a star's heliosheath experiencing bow shock.


You can see very clearly where the bow shock is, to the left of the star where glowing plasma and gases are colliding and piling up.

Continuing with this model, behind the bow shock, closer to the Sun, a point is reached where the pressure from interstellar plasma no longer exceeds the pressure from solar interplanetary plasma. It equals it. This point is called the heliopause. Just outside the heliopause, solar winds are no longer strong enough to push back the interstellar medium, and its outer edge should be marked by three changes - a drop in particle energy, a change in the direction of the magnetic field and an increase in the number of cosmic rays. The solar wind is essentially stopped. Termination shock is located just inside the heliopause, where the solar wind (the forward vector velocity component) hasn't yet been stopped but it abruptly slows to subsonic speed as it begins to feel the effects of interstellar wind pushing back on it.

Scrolling down you will see another NASA image of the heliosheath. Still operational, Voyager 1 approached the edge of the heliosphere last year (2012). The approach was signaled by a sharp increase in cosmic rays hitting it (many researchers agree that it passed termination shock in 2004). As Voyager 1 exits the heliosphere, scientists expect to see the direction of the magnetic field around it to change from the Sun's magnetic field to the direction of the interstellar magnetic field, but there is some current debate that it may have already exited the heliosphere. A sudden drop in lower energy particles detected along with a sudden rise in high-energy cosmic rays points to an exit, but the expected change in magnetic field didn't happen yet. Unfortunately, Voyager 1's magnetic field detector stopped working in 1990, so researchers have to infer the change in direction from other instruments onboard. Nevertheless, some experts mark the exit date at August 2012. Many other researchers believe Voyager 1 might be in a new unknown region, one that is not modeled for yet.


NASA's IBEX Imager Dispels the Heliospheric Bow Shock Model

NASA's Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX), launched in 2008, has imaged the entire interstellar boundary by imaging the glow from energetic neutral atoms (ENA). ENA imaging is an ingenious way to see things that are otherwise invisible. It works like this:

Mike Gruntman;Wikipedia
An energetic (fast moving) solar wind hydrogen ion collides with a neutral hydrogen atom present as background gas in the solar system. It "steals" charge from the atom to become an energetic neutral hydrogen atom, as shown left.

The new ENA shoots off in a straight line, shown below right, with almost the same velocity as the original energetic (fast) hydrogen ion. This atom, no longer bound by the magnetic field, glows momentarily much like a hot wire glows, and that glow is picked up by the imager.
Mike Gruntman;Wikipedi

ENA imagers can "see" planetary magnetospheres and the heliospheric boundary, where these collisions are most frequent, as there is a higher abundance of neutral atoms, especially hydrogen, in these regions.

The IBEX ENA imager found some unexpected things. First, it "saw" a narrow ribbon brighter than anything else in the heliopause region of space. The image below shows what it looked like in 2009, shown painted on the heliopause, with the locations of Voyager 1 and 2 included for reference. Six months later the image changed significantly.


No one knows yet exactly what process is creating the ENA ribbon, and the boundary itself is not a smooth bubble at all. It is an ever-changing three-dimensional ribbon that is far less uniform than once thought. IBEX has even discovered temporary knots in it. The first batch of data came from the solar minimum; researchers are eager to see how more intense and variable solar wind from the present solar maximum effects the boundary as it reaches it.

IBEX also measured the speeds of interstellar particles entering the heliospheric boundary and it found something even more surprising - the Sun is moving significantly slower than once thought - 83,700 km/h rather than around 95,000 km/h.

This motion should not be confused with the Sun's much higher orbital speed, mentioned earlier. Every star in the Milky Way experiences a very regular orbital motion and velocity, which can be calculated by using a reference star closer to the galactic center. Many stars also experience at least some random motion among other stars, called proper motion. Most stars are fairly fixed in their regular orbital loops but some are not. Barnard's star is an extreme example. It is shooting off radially outward from the galactic center at a right angle to all of its stellar neighbours, including the Sun. To calculate the Sun's random (proper) motion speed prior to the IBEX data, scientists used the average motion of other stars in the Sun's vast neighbourhood and measured the Sun's motion relative to it, a less reliable and less direct method.

No Bow Shock For the Sun

The Sun's new adjusted speed is not sufficient to create bow shock at the boundary. The forward vector component of the solar wind particles is no longer high enough to be supersonic. It should create a bow wave instead, where pressure waves have enough time to spread out ahead of the moving heliosheath, like a wave front at the bow of a ship. This way, particles avoid a rapid drop in pressure (shock). No bow shock changes how the solar system is modeled. All the models that include the effects of bow shock must now be tossed out. Keep in mind that the two images of the heliosphere in this article are now outdated. No bow shock means that the heliosphere is not compressed and weakened nearly as much as once thought. It may protect the solar system from cosmic rays much better than predicted. The heliopshere has just become even more interesting!

In addition to a new intensified interest in the mechanics of the heliosheath, scientists also wonder how protection from cosmic ray flux, which varies as the Sun enters new regions of the galaxy along its rotation period, might have influenced evolution on Earth, and how the heliospheres of other stars might influence life in their solar systems, if life elsewhere exists. Should a star's heliosheath be examined, along with the presence of liquid water, for example, when scientists look for habitable alien worlds? These are questions that researchers, with increasing imaging sophistication, may be able to test.

The Heliosphere And The 11-Year Solar Cycle

When the magnetic field diminishes before it suddenly changes polarity during solar maximum, the heliosphere doesn't just shut off. Other complicated magnetic field structures, which are not fully understood, appear to fill the void while a new oppositely directed field builds up. The heliosphere, however, is influenced by solar wind. Just how much its shape and size change along with variations in solar weather are questions the IBEX imager might soon answer.

Sun As Protector

The heliopause is the outermost boundary of the solar wind. Although the Sun itself bombards Earth with radiation and high-speed particles, the Sun's powerful magnetosphere protects Earth from an even greater threat - galactic radiation. The heliosphere deflects about 90% of galactic cosmic rays and Earth's magnetosphere deflects most of the rest of it.

Cosmic "Rays" And Gamma "Rays"

Along with our magnetosphere, our atmosphere also protects us. It blocks cosmic rays with energies below 1GeV. 1 GeV is one billion, or 1 x 109, electron volts. This is the bottom of the cosmic ray energy scale. I mentioned earlier that cosmic rays generally range in energy from 109 to 1021 eV and possibly even higher. The most energetic cosmic rays discovered so far are protons accelerated by incredibly strong magnetic fields associated with black holes in the centers of active galaxies. Cosmic rays are particles with mass that have enormous velocity, so they carry incredible momentum. You may be tempted to confuse these with gamma rays, which also have very high energy. "Ray" is not an especially good name for either phenomenon. Robert Millikan first coined the term "cosmic ray" in the 1920's, believing that what he observed in his experiments was EM radiation. Cosmic rays are actually energetic particles with mass, most of which are protons (hydrogen nuclei, 99%) but alpha particles (helium nuclei, 1%) and electrons (1%) also make up primary rays. When these ultra-fast particles collide with other particles in space or in atmospheres, they create new particles upon collision and these are called secondary cosmic rays. Gamma rays (and X-rays), on the other hand, are high-energy massless photons of electromagnetic (EM) radiation. They don't interact with magnetic fields like cosmic rays do, having no charge to them. But photons, too, have momentum even though they do not have mass. The momentum of a photon is not simply mass x velocity. It is better called relativistic momentum where relativistic mass (energy has a mass equivalent) replaces classical mass.

Gamma rays have the highest energy of all EM photons, but even the highest energy gamma rays (1.6 x 1013 eV, detected in 2011 coming from an active galaxy called Markarian 421) do not approach the extremes of cosmic ray energy.

To get a sense of scale, only gamma ray photons have energies that approach 1 GeV (1 billion electron volts), equivalent to the lowest energy cosmic ray particles. A photon of visible light has around 2 eV of energy, while UVA and UVB ultraviolet photons, between 3 and 4.5 eV respectively, have enough energy to cause sunburn and skin damage. Cosmic EM radiation (not cosmic rays) consists not only of gamma rays but also of photons of all energies. That's why astronomers can capture distant stars and gases, using UV, ultraviolet, X-ray, visible light and radio wave imagers, for example. Cosmic radiation (both particles and photons) comes from many sources in the universe, such as the centers (black holes) of active galaxies, supernovae, quasars and gamma ray bursts. It consists of cosmic EM radiation (gamma rays, X-rays, etc.) as well as electrons and the nuclei of elements (protons, alpha particles and a few even larger nuclei) blasted out into space at almost the speed of light.

Cosmic Radiation and Astronauts

All of these kinds of radiation have tremendous energy and momentum, so they are very dangerous to astronauts outside of Earth's protective atmosphere, where radiation (both particles and gamma rays) easily penetrates spacecraft and people. Some online articles suggest that electromagnetic shielding might someday be used to protect astronauts from gamma rays while on an eventual manned trip to Mars, but, as I understand it, this would be challenging. EM shielding generally consists of a metal mesh or foam where the holes are smaller than the wavelength of the EM radiation; the EM radiation gets reflected away from the surface. If you look at a microwave oven door you can see a fine mesh. This mesh keeps microwaves in but it lets visible light (smaller wavelengths) through so you can see inside the oven. Gamma ray wavelengths are extremely short, less than a trillionth of a metre, so small they can get right into atoms. However, relatively dense and thick materials, like our atmosphere, block gamma radiation very effectively and we will explore how that works later on in this article.

Cosmic ray (particle) shielding is also still a work in progress. One (ingenious and perhaps gross) idea is to use the astronaut's poop, solving two "problems" at once. At least this is on the table for a planned 2018 private mission. The water content in poop supplies a large (particle-absorbing) nuclei-to-volume ratio. I suspect it would absorb some gamma rays as well. Magnetic shielding has been studied more extensively, and this might be a more reliable option for astronauts. A current-carrying ring or bubble could enclose a space capsule, inducing a particle-deflecting magnetic field, but the ring would have to generate a very intense magnetic field in order to deflect very energetic cosmic protons, etc., and astronauts inside the bubble would be subjected to prolonged intense magnetic field exposure with unknown consequences. Cosmic radiation shielding is a challenging problem that is under intense investigation as NASA prepares to ultimately send astronauts to Mars. Unless shielding can be improved, these people will be subjected to radiation similar to what Apollo astronauts experienced (between 1.2 and 1.4 mSv/day - about the same as a CT scan) and for a much longer period of time (and the destination, Mars,  has very little protective atmosphere and magnetosphere).

The Heliosphere - A Bubble of Calm in a Violent Cosmic Sea

The center of the Milky Way glows with gamma rays, as galactic wind particles slam into interstellar dust and gas. In 2010, NASA's Fermi Gamma Ray Space Telescope (GLAST) discovered two gigantic gamma ray bubbles (shown below in a NASA artist's rendition) coming from the center of the Milky Way. These gamma ray bubbles, extending 30,000 light years from the center, likely come from a past violent episode of black hole consumption. There is a black hole (Sagittarius A*) with a mass nearly 4 million times the mass of the Sun lurking at the center of the Milky Way. Usually, it gives off only faint radiation as it consumes matter, but starting 30,000 years ago, it experienced at least one, and possibly a series of outbursts of activity.


The Sun is about 26,000 light years from the galactic center, so what do these bubbles of gamma rays mean for us? Apparently, our heliosphere has proven itself to be a good protector, as these gamma rays have already reached us causing no apparent damage (they've reached, and been detected by, GLAST, which is in low Earth orbit).

How the Heliosphere Protects Earth Against Cosmic Rays and Gamma Rays

Nearly all cosmic rays are deflected by the magnetic field of the Sun (as well as Earth's magnetic field). The magnetic field lines bend their trajectories away because they are charged particles acted on by the Lorentz force.

Gamma rays, unlike plasma particles, do not interact with the magnetic field of the heliosphere (with the exception of vacuum birefringence in very strong magnetic fields such as around magnetars. In order to be attenuated, they must be absorbed by the nuclei in atoms or plasma. There are three mechanisms that do this, based on the energy of the gamma photons.

When a lower energy (< 50keV) gamma ray photon strikes an atomic nucleus, it causes an electron to be ejected from the atom. The electron has the same energy as the gamma photon minus the binding energy of that electron, resulting in an overall dampening effect. This is called the photoelectric effect.

The photoelectric effect becomes less significant for gamma photons with energies between 100 keV and 10 MeV. Here, Compton scattering dampens the energy of gamma photons. The gamma photon strikes a nucleus and an electron is ejected, but in this case, another new gamma photon is also released. Its energy is lower than original gamma photon and its trajectory is different. This is why it's called "scattering."

Cosmic radiation gamma photons tend to have far higher energies, exceeding 10 million eV (or 10MeV). Here, energy absorption (attenuation) comes mostly through pair production. A gamma photon interacts with the electric field of a nucleus, which converts it into the rest mass of an electron-positron pair. Any energy the gamma photon had that exceeded the pair's rest mass becomes the new particle's kinetic energy as well as the recoil velocity of the nucleus. The electron strikes other particles and the positron strikes another atom's electron, annihilating with it and emitting two new gamma photons (with a minimum energy of 0.5 MeV), causing Compton scattering and so on.

Any of the free electrons released or produced in these processes has enough energy to cause significant ionization of atoms struck by the radiation. Cosmic gamma photons strike mostly bare protons in heliospheric plasma, so pair production is the significant energy absorption mechanism.

Earth's Atmosphere Offers the Best Gamma Radiation Protection

A thick slab of lead, for example, has large nuclei and a high density, so it offers good gamma ray shielding, especially to lower energy gamma photons, but Earth's atmosphere, because it is so thick (there are a lot of atoms to go through), is actually much more effective. In fact, it offers almost 100% protection from cosmic gamma rays. It's almost totally opaque to them. Earth, however, is vulnerable to a gamma ray burst. A gamma ray burst is the most powerful explosion in the universe, and it is made up of the highest energy photons known in the universe.

Luckily, two factors are on our side. First, gamma ray bursts are only created when very massive stars collapse as supernova explosions or when two stars collide, and only a few occur in the Milky Way every million years. Second, these bursts shoot very narrow beams of radiation, especially in the case of polar jets. A beam of radiation has to be directed right at Earth in order to do any damage. The image below shows how a massive star could collapse into a black hole with a jet of gamma rays (gamma ray burst) emanating from the center of its axis of rotation.

Nicolle Rager Fuller of the NSF;Wikipedia
If Earth was unlucky enough to be in the crosshairs of a gamma ray burst, we could be blasted with as much energy in a few seconds as what the Sun generates during its entire lifetime. A burst would last only a few tens of seconds at most so it would strike only one hemisphere. We, and other life, would not be blasted directly with gamma radiation, however. Our atmosphere would attenuate almost all gamma ray radiation, even very high-energy photons, by the three processes described earlier, before any struck the surface. There would be a visually bright flash as gamma rays strike the atmosphere, but that is also unlikely to harm most organisms. We would experience a brief bright flash of visible light, but the real threat would have just begun.

The Indirect Threat Of a Gamma Ray Burst

Ground level effects on Earth from a gamma ray burst would be indirect. Such a burst, if close enough, would have significant effects on the chemistry of the atmosphere. High-energy gamma photons would break apart molecules of nitrogen (N2) and oxygen (O2) and temporarily ionize them. The atoms would then recombine into significant amounts of nitrous oxides, NO and NO2 (which would then be split by a gamma photon into NO). These molecules do three kinds of damage.

First, they deplete the ozone layer (O3) by reacting with it. The ozone layer is built up by UV light from the Sun striking O2 molecules and splitting them into two O atoms. Each O atom quickly reacts with two more O2 molecules, creating two O3 molecules. O3 is unstable so it soon splits back into an O2 and an O. This cyclic process maintains a balance between O2 and O3 in the upper stratosphere, maintaining the ozone layer. NO catalyzes the oxygen recombination reaction, reducing O3 abundance (at ground level, in contrast, NO2 contributes to ozone pollution). With the ozone layer stripped away, deadly UV radiation will flood Earth's surface. Increased UV radiation, persisting for perhaps many years before the ozone layer is replenished, would be the single most deadly threat of a gamma ray burst.

Second, NO2 is a brown gas so it may also significantly reduce sunlight striking the ground (it absorbs in the visible range so it will provide no UV protection). Reduced solar insolation, as it is called, might be enough to lead to an extended period of climate cooling.

Third, the only way the atmosphere can return to normal and remove nitrous oxides is by precipitating nitric acid (HNO3). Some experts think the amount (and rate) of acid deposited might be harmful to some life such as thin-skinned amphibians but plants might not be as seriously damaged and they might even benefit from the increased availability of nitrogen.

B. C. Thomas at the Department of Physics and Astronomy believes that the atmosphere, based on current modeling, would recover from a typical gamma ray burst in a little over a decade, so Earth itself would recover quite quickly, leaving the question of how life would recover from increased UV radiation. This kind of radiation damages DNA molecules and it may lower metabolic rates, photosynthetic capacity and delay or arrest cell division. In multicellular organisms it could delay development, cause birth effects and increase cancer rates. Some researchers believe that Earth may already have been hit with a gamma ray burst, triggering the Ordovician mass extinction, 440 million years ago, when roughly two thirds of marine life (all animal life was marine then) went extinct.
Even an event several thousand light years from Earth could destroy half the ozone layer and possibly trigger a mass extinction.

The Sun Conclusion

The universe, while seemingly almost timeless to us, is a very violent place. The Sun exists among countless other stars, where physical forces are continuously at play on an incredibly large scale.

The Sun is made of space gas. Mostly hydrogen and a little helium were squeezed hard enough and in enough quantity to create an incredibly complex ongoing spherical nuclear fusion explosion. Life on Earth evolved to make use of that energy.

The physics of the universe makes stars like our Sun inevitable and perhaps even life, relying on their energy, inevitable as well. We humans are very transient delicate beings. Eventually, all Earth life will perish as the Sun evolves into a white dwarf, and this remnant may last long enough to bear witness to the end of the universe itself.